A unique challenge begins this episode: The eight remaining cast members are divided evenly and play four-handed games of bunco, a dice game preferred by many older members of the Barefoot household. The winners of each game will have an advantage in the next team challenge. Deb defeats Casey, Pam, and Bobbington in the first match, while Tim bests ButtaFly, Adam, and Meredith in the second. The opponents then become teammates for the main challenge, with the bunco winners becoming team captains.
The task for them is to make a pitch for a TV show that would fit on the BMN schedule. Deb's idea is "Fast Times," about a race-car driver who uses the DNA of various stars of the past to gain an advantage. Casey is the driver, Pam his wife, Deb the driver's publicist, and Bobbington a security guard. Tim has a show concept called "Hayride Rescue," in which struggling farms and ranches are turned around based on historic themes. Tim is the mastermind, Adam and Meredith the curators, and ButtaFly the publicist. The winning team gets a five-minute program on the BMN website and a one-hour special on the main network.
The pitches are heard not only by regular judges Brandon McLamb and Brian Warner, but also by BMN advisor Steve Beverly. Both pitches are looked at with a very critical eye. Deb's team was praised for having a "cool retro idea that somehow, in a strange way, fits well with this network" (McLamb) but Warner and McLamb debated about whether the show would use too much modern technology. "It may be too much of a shock to the system for some viewers," Warner argues. As for "Hayride Rescue," McLamb and Beverly love the idea of celebrating rural culture through renovation, but Warner is opposed, saying there are simply too many shows on TV like that one. Beverly has the last word: "Once you have a winning idea, you want to spread it to as many places as possible."
Beverly must have been very persuasive, as "Hayride Rescue" wins. Then Shandi Finnessey announces a surprise: the second double-elimination of the season, which will leave only six competitors. When Pam is told that she is the biggest target in the house, she replies that "only you can vote me out, and I have faith that you won't because I have played a great game so far." McLamb responds that "I just don't have that faith anymore, not after the big risk you took. Looking back, 'Fast Times' is not what BMN wants; it's just too modern. We always look to the future by reviving our past. Maybe the past is there on this show, but it's pretty hard to see. Pam is the first contestant sent home; seconds later, Deb is eliminated for endorsing the concept and "letting Pam walk all over her."
At the end of the show, celebrations go on inside the room, and a cloth doll representing Pam is buried in one of the garbage carts.